After the massacre: Remembering October 7

S8
E59
38mins

Three years after October 7, Noam Weissman visits the Tkuma car graveyard, Kibbutz Be’eri, and Netiv Ha’Asara to ask how Israelis remember tragedy while rebuilding their homes and lives. Through conversations with survivors and community members, this episode explores grief, resilience, Zionism, Jewish memory, and the responsibility to tell the stories of those who were lost, as well as those determined to carry on.

Subscribe to this podcast

Three years ago, the world turned upside down. For the first few weeks after October 7, we stumbled around in a daze, looking for the grown-ups in the room, for an explanation, for a doorway out of the nightmare.

But the world continued to spin. Through hostage releases and hostage rescues. Through the retrieval of precious bodies we had hoped to recover alive. Through rockets from Lebanon and Yemen and Iran. Through a seven-front war that never quite ended. Through college encampments and firebombings of synagogues and public debates about antisemitism and free speech. Through the terrible scenes emerging from Gaza. Through the first anniversary. Then the second.

Now, we approach the third.

The shock has subsided. The grief has not. And neither have the two questions that have dogged us since the moment we realized that this was no ordinary attack.

One, about the past: how did this happen?

The other, about the future: what happens next?

The first might be answerable, but the Israeli government has yet to establish an independent commission of inquiry into the failures that led to that day – a point of serious contention and concern for many Israelis. 

The second question is not and has never been answerable, or even predictable – though Israelis have different ideas about what should happen next. You’ll meet some of them in this episode.

But the truth is, neither of those questions is the point. Not right now. Not today. What I want to focus on isn’t how this happened, but how we remember it. Memory is at the core of Judaism. Not living in the past, but telling and retelling the story of our past to understand ourselves. To make sense of our present. 

So today, I want to introduce you to three different Israelis, all of whom memorialize that day in different ways. And though they hold different beliefs and have internalized different lessons, all three are motivated by the same impulse as our ancestors, who told and retold the story of the Exodus from Egypt, down the generations for thousands of years. They believe, as I do, that as long as the story survives, as long as people remain to tell it, all is not yet lost. 

—

I met Shai on an uncomfortably hot day in July.

Shai grew up in Sderot, once called the “bomb shelter capital of the world.” Its proximity to Gaza made the town a frequent target of Hamas rockets. On October 7th, Hamas terrorists seized the Sderot Police Station, prompting an hours-long firefight that ended with the IDF bulldozing the building. In total, 72 people were murdered in Sderot that day, including 13 elderly sightseers returning from a trip to the Dead Sea.

So memorializing is personal for Shai. 

But his memorial site isn’t in his hometown. It’s a little farther south, along Highway 232, now known as kvish hadamim, the road of blood.

This is where Hamas ambushed civilians in their cars, as they drove frantically away from the Nova festival site. The images are seared into my mind: Car after car, bullet-riddled or torched, stalled on the road. Some with doors open, bodies slumped over steering wheels or hanging out of doors. Some with splintered windshields and bloodstains on the upholstery. Some with charred bodies inside.

Eventually, responders needed to clear the road.

They towed the cars stuck on the highway and at the Nova site to a temporary holding location near Moshav Tkuma, a religious cooperative farming community 7 miles from the Gaza border.

Three years later, that temporary location has become a permanent memorial for 1,600 destroyed cars and the people who once drove them. They’re cordoned off behind an electrified fence, which bears a massive sign that announces, in three languages, that you have arrived at The Burnt Vehicles Compound – Temporary Site. At the bottom is a line from Psalms 18:40, Tehillim Yud Chet: Mem, left untranslated:

 וַתְּאַזְּרֵ֣נִי חַ֭יִל לַמִּלְחָמָ֑ה תַּכְרִ֖יעַ קָמַ֣י תַּחְתָּֽי׃

You have girded me with strength for battle, brought low my adversaries before me.

Maybe that became true later, as Israel hunted down Sinwar, Haniyeh, Deif, Nasrallah, and Khamenei. Or maybe it’s true in an entirely different way. The sight of the destroyed cars does awaken a kind of inner strength: the strength it takes to remember. The strength it takes to tell and retell the story of what happened here.

Fittingly, the Tkuma Car Graveyard has the feel of a junkyard. Most of the cars are twisted beyond recognition, shredded into ribbons that resemble abstract sculptures. Others are just husks: a metal frame, some wheels. The idea of a car, rather than the thing itself. Poking out from the tangle are isolated parts: a headrest with its leather peeled away, or a single orphaned wheel. 

Standing apart from the so-called “wall” are the charred ambulances and emergency service vehicles, draped in flags bearing their respective logos. They are all that remain of the first responders who barreled headfirst into a massacre, murdered while trying to rescue others. 

Next to the so-called “Car Wall” are cars that look almost normal. Except for the blown-out windows, or the bullet holes. Except for a crumpled door, a splintered windshield. 

And, of course, the fact that no one will ever drive them again. Their owners and passengers are dead.

Most of the cars belonged to Israeli civilians. But a handful carried Hamas from Gaza over the border. They, too, are on display: the white vans that are so familiar from all the nightmare footage of that day. 

As we stand outside the electrified fence, Shai explains exactly what I’m looking at.

[SHAI INSERT]

SHAI

And what we have here today are hundreds of vehicles that were torched by Hamas on October 7th, that were used by Hamas because they took some of the vehicles from the communities and then they used it to drive people around hostages and stuff of the sort. We have here also vehicles that were shot at. So, when you go inside, you can actually see some of the windows have bullet holes in them. You can see dozens of bullet holes in each and one of these vehicles. They have the ambulance from the Nova Festival grounds, the one that was attacked by Hamas, of course, the paramedic that was working and it was murdered. They have here some of the cars of Nova participants. They have their cars of, actually, they have two pickup trucks of terrorists on display here, so that people would be able to see what this looked like, what they were using. Motorcycles that were used by Hamas or Gazans, depends what to come in and loot the communities and so forth. Basically, this is evidence of what took place on that day and they created a wall of these torched vehicles to show the immensity of what took place. For most people, you know, they never saw this. They don’t understand, but this is what this is supposed to be.

NOAM

When I look at this historically and I think of when you get to Nalbagh, when you get to Ben Gurion and when you land and then you drive, you used to drive towards Jerusalem, you would see these tanks that were on the sides of the road. Do you remember this? Yeah, the armored vehicles.

SHAI

The armored drone, yeah.

NOAM

Yeah, yeah. You would see them on the side of the road and be like, “What’s going on?” And the answer was those were tanks from a war that Israel was fighting against another enemy country that was fighting a war. This is a totally different feeling for me because this is not Israeli soldiers and Israeli armored tanks fighting against another country. This is another group of people coming into the boundaries and the borders of Israel and really destroying, killing, burning people who were defenseless.

SHAI

 Basic, yes. I mean, this is exactly what you’re saying. Whereas when you look at something of this nature, when it’s regular war, you see armored vehicles that are designed for that. These are regular vehicles of people that went for a party, people that were sleeping in their house that morning and woke up to this hill, people that were just driving on the road with their family going for a day out, have a picnic, stuff of the sort, and encountered a stranger. To them, a stranger that was standing there with AK-47 and an RPG and took them out on the road, just murdered them like they were nothing or kidnapped them out of their car. And that’s really the cost for the civilian population in Israel on that particular day is what we see when we look at this. And I don’t know if we’re capturing this or not, but it goes as far as I can see.

NOAM

 It’s all far down, yeah. That’s very far down.

SHAI

 That’s what you really see when you look there.

NOAM

 That’s the amount, and it’s just devastating.

SHAI

 Traumatizing image.

[BACK TO NOAM]

The car graveyard is just that: a graveyard. It is a monument to bravery and horror, not the site of the horrors themselves. It’s devastating, of course. But it’s devastation at a remove: the difference between a museum exhibit and ground zero. 

The next site I want to tell you about is ground zero.

In the weeks after the attack, Kibbutz Be’eri came to symbolize the cruelty of the massacre. 10% of Be’eri’s residents were murdered that day, and dozens taken hostage. Nine of those hostages did not return alive.


Scrolling through the casualties is an exercise in despair. The same last names, repeated over and over. Four Sharabis. Four Evens. Five Biras. It goes on and on. Family members of all ages. The youngest victim was ten months old. The oldest, 88.

Dr. Alon Pauker is a soft-spoken history professor, who – fittingly – specializes in the history of the kibbutz movement. But there are no tweed patches or pipes here. Like all Israelis, he dresses informally: t-shirt, jeans, the kind of all-purpose sandals you can wear to go hiking. As we sit together in the grass, surrounded by trees, I try to reconcile our peaceful surroundings with the story he is telling me.

Because his tone is so matter-of-fact. But his words… his words are horrifying. He doesn’t know why the terrorists skipped over his home as they rampaged through his community, massacring his neighbors. But he remembers being rescued. He remembers the firefight raging around him. The smoke rising from the buildings. The sounds of battle.

Despite the trauma of those sights – or maybe because of it – he is among the 100 residents who have returned to rebuild the kibbutz.

But his vision for rebuilding goes well beyond Be’eri. He imagines a unified Israeli society, coming together despite stubborn differences in opinion on just about everything. As Israel faces down perhaps the most significant – and contentious – election in its history, this feels like an audacious dream. The dividing lines between religious and secular, Ashkenazi and Mizrahi, left and right, have never felt wider. 

But hope remains. In the wake of October 7, those dividing lines disappeared.

Not permanently. But long enough for seemingly unexpected alliances to emerge. The Haredi men lining up to enlist. The Orthodox responders who hopped in their ambulances as soon as they heard an attack was unfolding, even though it was both Shabbat AND a holiday. A number of West Bank “settlers” raced south as well, in hopes of rescuing someone. It didn’t matter that the kibbutzim are largely left-leaning, full of people who believe that West Bank settlements and checkpoints are an obstacle to peace. For a few days, the horrors erased the political divide – although, of course, that didn’t last. 

If unifying Israelis wasn’t challenging enough, Dr. Pauker is fighting for a world in which an independent Palestinian state exists side by side with Israel. October 7th has not dampened that conviction – though he’s aware that both Israelis and Palestinians have a long road to walk before that vision is a reality. 

Our conversation began with pain. But it ended somewhere surprising.

[INSERT ALON]

Noam 

right now we’re sitting in Be’eri yeah… and how many people were killed here and how many people were taken hostage?

Alon

 one hundred and two were killed thirty for being hostages, twenty-one came back, some of them were killed or murdered in prison while being hostage in Gaza that’s our deep disagreement with the government that didn’t make enough to bring it back earlier and the twenty-one came back alive we are happy regarding that but all in all we lost ten percent of our community it’s from the Holocaust you just can’t imagine

Noam 

so what was life like here before the 7th of October just describe, this is a beautiful pristine area, I had never been to Be’eri, what is Be’eri famous for?

Alon

we built our famous print factory that is our biggest economic power and we built a really strong society and strong economy and we used to say that when I came here, I wasn’t born here, I was born in Kibbutz, and I immigrated here, so one of the members told me, you know that while you’re going to die, you’re going to hell, so I tell you, why are you talking with me like that? He told me, because in a paradise you already exist, so we thought about our Kibbutz as a paradise, and then the hell time came in the massacre in October 7 and our hope is to, with our pioneering spirit, like if you can say it like that to rebuild it as a paradise again.

Noam 

 What was the day of October the 7th like as a survivor, you are a survivor of October the 7th? What was the thing, tell me what was it like for you?

Alon

 I really don’t know even what to start with, because it was a disaster, I mean, after half an hour we understand that we are in an event that wasn’t ever, and we in a water group, we started to understand the we didn’t know the biggest, or how big is the catastrophe, we knew there is a catastrophe, me and my wife were lucky enough they didn’t come into our home, just we were lucky too, and then after, but we was like in a battlefield, we had the shots all around, our children, after the army, so the small separate apartment, and we all came out with nobody, our family was murdered

Noam 

 So you were telling me before about a very unlikely couple of the settlers from the West Bank, Judea, and Samaria having some sort of relationship with the kibbutz settlers down here. I would think that there’s different religious sensibilities, different political sensibilities. How do you have that dialogue?

Alon

I understood some days after that what happened is a difficult event for sure of the state of Israel. So if something like that happened, the October 6th is early, just collapsed that day. And if it collapsed, you can’t rebuild it in the same way. It’s and all of us, all of us has to think what you are doing different. We don’t have to blame the others. There is some, the government is the government. And the blame is on them for sure. But all of us have to think how we work differently from now on. I understand it in the days after the massacre. And then I started to speak with people and I said, okay, if we have to build it differently, we have to, if we understood something in October 7 that the Israeli state is not existing for sure. We thought everything is okay, we can fight each other. No. If we are not all of us together, we just won’t stand against our enemies and against ourselves as a society. So we have to gather all the Israeli part to rebuild the Israeli society. And if I understood this, I must go to the people that I’m not agree with them. I started to talk with people they agree with me and then tomorrow, two years ago, July 9, 2024, it was my first time as a leftist to cross the green line to the territories and say, okay, we are now talking. We organized it. And then, it was the hostages’ time there and the fighting inside Israel, so they are belonging to the white-wing political side but they came to be with us in our fighting to bring back the hostages.

 So a deep solidarity became a deep mutual trust. And then we say, okay, if we have to build this Israeli society, and if we have to agree, let’s agree. We made a journey toward the task to agree. 

Noam 

 So what does it mean that you are a leftist now? Meaning, what does it what does that mean with regard to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict? I assume that on October 6th, you’re somebody that was fighting for a two state solution, believing in a two state solution, wanting Palestinians to have sovereignty and autonomy. And after October 7th, now what? What does it mean that you’re a leftist?

Alon

 I said, I tell, I’m not a…

Noam 

 Do you think you want the Palestinians to have a state?

Alon

 In the end, maybe. But what we’re… Let’s start from the fact. Because this is the problem. Between the river and the sea, the Jewish are half of the population. The settlers ignore and they admit, ignore this fact. Okay, just when settling places and okay, what will be with the Palestinians? What’s your solution? No solution. We say, okay, you are not talking about solution, you are the problem. The Palestinians must have state. What were they saying in October 7th? We can’t give the Palestinians state. No, they are here. Stop to ignore it. So if, but what the problem is, we’ve freeze each other. We spoke about two state solution. They ignore the situation.

Noam 

 And the solution isn’t to transfer them out or to kill them?

Alon

 No, what we agreed, that the solution must be democratic.

Noam

What would you say to the American Jewish community on the left, who they identify as left-wing and their identification of left-wing is either to, you know, sometimes it’s to oppose Israeli policy or to be very angry at the current government in Israel, or in some cases a lot of the American Jewish left has moved away from Zionism. So what would you say to them, who you identify as a lefty from Israel, what’s your statement to them?

Alon

 Excellent and important question, I’ll tell you. There is a reason, a deep reason to be very angry with our government. Because our government is like I feel sometimes in the hostages’ time and what happened in October 7, and you know that you just don’t feel the care regarding us. I mean, we sometimes even say that our government is fighting against our state and our society. Okay, but we are zoned. What’s happened in the progressive left side in the US is just something like craziness. They mix things and they don’t understand the situation. You can’t identify the Palestinian struggle with Hamas. I mean, I want to tell everyone, would you agree to live 3 or 4 kilometers beside a territory that is controlled by something like ISIS? And the Hamas is not less difficult than ISIS even more. Okay, what would you do if this terrorist is fighting against you? You will fight against them. So don’t get confused. 

Noam 

 What is, this is a question I keep on asking everyone here. A lot of people are moving far away from Zionism outside of Israel. You keep on calling yourself a Zionist. What does it mean to be a Zionist?

Noam

What’s your definition of a Zionist?

Alon

 Of Zionist to have an independent state for the Jewish people and the other citizens that are in our state. I mean in a long term process we must have and I want to have an independent Jewish state.

Noam 

 I think Democratic or no?

Alon

 It must be democratic.

Noam 

What’s the future of Be’eri? What’s the future of this beautiful beautiful place?

Alon

 Again the future of the Arie depends on the future of the state of Israel. I mean the young generation of Israel has a task and it take a lot of them are taking the task if we rebuild the Israeli society we rebuild BERI BERI is a strong community even nowadays it will be a paradise again but it will be a paradise again if we can fix the Israeli atmosphere and the Israeli situation which now is under a deep dangers and I’m not speaking about Iran and I’m not speaking about Hezbollah if we are strong from between us we’ll deal with our enemies.

Noam 

 And here’s my last question for you what’s the what’s the one thing that you think that the world most misunderstands about Israeli society in general that you want to just clarify for people from your perspective I mean I’m meeting with so many different types of Israelis we met with Bedouin leaders we met with people in high tech we met with people from kibbutzim we’re meeting with people from Jerusalem all different types of people but what’s the thing that you think that people don’t understand about Israeli society that you want to from your perspective clarify

Alon

 I don’t know if don’t understand the Israeli society maybe the deep identification of solidarity but leave it I think the most think that people are not understanding not the Israeli society but the situation of the conflict

Noam 

 what don’t they understand

Alon

 I mean what we spoke about they just confused the legitimized Palestinian struggle is part that are legitimized not the terror and what’s happened in October 7 and they don’t understand that Hamas Iran Hezbollah are the enemies of all the western world I think about Mamadani the

Noam 

 New York mayor?

Alon

 they just don’t understand I don’t agree with them I think they deeply don’t understand the situation

Noam 

 oh wow you think they just don’t understand this is not a matter of oppressor that’s not what this is over here no it’s not what it is it’s a people who want you to die and is it the Palestinian people or Hamas

Alon

 Hamas, all the Palestinians are the same look as the children I went to Gaza the situation was different

Noam 

 you used to go to Gaza?

Alon

 yeah, there was the border until the intifada of 1987 the border was somewhat open my mother in Niroz, she was on charge of the building the workers came from Gaza we had friends there that’s what I tell to my new friends from the West Bank that we helped the extremists because we didn’t give any kind of solution we as a government must every morning say we want peace this is the solution what you are doing but we made nothing so the extremists took power there it’s not just because what happened there we have a responsibility

Noam 

 so once the Palestinians change the education system change the pay to slay change their mentality you think there could be a future between the two peoples

Alon

 there must be a future I don’t believe in this thing about people that are not people that have difficulties because they are Palestinian, because they are Muslim everything, I’m a teacher everything is a question of education but it will take years we have to build a trust it will take a generation

Noam  

thank you so much for your time thank you for this conversation and from one teacher to another teacher I agree everything comes down to education everything thank you

[back to Noam]

As I record this, Be’eri is being rebuilt: row after row of low white houses with Spanish tiles and shaded porches, still unfinished. The kibbutz has decided to leave a single ruined house standing: a haunting symbol of everything that happened here, alone amidst all the rebirth.

25 minutes north of Be’eri, just steps from the Gaza border, the members of Netiv Ha’Asara have made a different choice.

For now, they have left the ruins standing. Every bullet hole, every bloodstain, every burned house: a reminder of the day that Hamas terrorists on motorized paragliders swooped in from the sky, murdering 20 residents before the IDF could intervene. 

It is, perhaps, a fitting memorial in a place that is itself named after the dead. Netiv Ha’Asara means “Path of the Ten,” in honor of ten IDF soldiers whose helicopter crashed in 1972, while they were carrying out a top-secret mission. It might sound morbid, but it’s hardly the only community in Israel named for the dead. 

And the memory of trauma is everywhere in Netiv Ha’asara, side by side with life. A whopping 83%of the community’s population has returned, along with 12 new families who have chosen to make their homes amidst the wreckage. 

I don’t know how to describe that decision. Defiance? Bravery? Grace?

My guide to this community, Micha, isn’t thinking about how to define or describe his decision. He was born in Netiv Ha’Asara, and has built his life here: a wife, a house, three kids. He looks too young to have adult kids, in that delirious mid-20s stage where everything seems possible, where you can go anywhere you want. But like their grandparents, like their parents, his children want this. Micha has already bought the land to build a house for one of his kids, amid the wreckage of their neighbors’ homes. Amid the background noise of explosions from Gaza, a reminder that the war isn’t over. 

But when I ask Micha why stay, he seems almost confused by the question. This is his home, site of the best and worst moments of his life. And he is on a mission to keep it alive, both as it was, and as it will be. He speaks about it with such humility that I almost miss how profound his words are. But as we talk next to the pool he built with his own hands, I begin to understand that in many ways, our mission is the same. 

[MICHA INSERT]

Noam 

Micha. Thank you for welcoming me to your house. Thank you for coming. It’s an awesome for me. It’s a beautiful house.

Micha

Thank you very much.

Noam 

 I love your pool.

Micha

Thank you.

Noam 

 It’s an excellent pool. After this conversation, we will skinny-dip.

(Both Laugh)

Noam 

 We won’t really, relax everyone. But no, this is a very heavy place where we are right now, but it’s also your home.

Micha

It’s my home.

Noam 

 It’s your home.

Micha

 Yes.

Noam 

 And you were telling me earlier the story of how you got here. And I want to understand a little bit more about your background as a person. So where are your grandparents from?

Micha

My grandparents also lived in a village near Kiryat Gat. My parents, after they got married, my mother was actually eight months pregnant when they moved to the new Nativ Ha’Asara. I was born, as I said, in Nativ Ha’Asara. I’ve lived all my life in Nativ Ha’Asara.

Noam 

 You’ve lived here your whole life?

Micha

 My whole life. I’ve spent 25 years at my parents’ house in Nativ Ha’Asara. When I was 25, I got married. Two years later, we’ve built this house that we are standing in, that we are staying here. And I’ve raised three kids in this house.

Noam 

 And after the 7th of October, you still feel comfortable living here?

Micha

 You have to understand, there is a hierarchy, okay? I decide nothing, okay? I’ve got my wife and kids. They decide. I do whatever they say. When they decide that it’s safe for them to come home, to come back to Nativa Asara, we did it. It didn’t happen in a day, didn’t happen in a week, didn’t even happen in a month. It’s a procedure. It takes time.

Noam 

 How long did it take?

Micha

 About three months.

Noam

What do you see as the future then? What do you see as the future? You were telling me a story and you were showing me an incredibly painful story of the 78-year-old woman, Chavik. Chavik was in it, yes. He was killed, shot nine times, point blank. And from Palestinians within two miles of you that came in paragliding to this very neighborhood where we’re sitting right now. So then what is the future between Israelis, between you and Palestinians? What is the future? I have no idea. What should the plan be?

Micha

 I think that people which are smarter than me, has more ranks on their shoulders than I do. I’m a small person.

Noam 

 What do you want the plan to be? What should happen with the Palestinians?

Micha

 I don’t care what will be on the other side. It can be war, it can be peace. I want my kids. I have three kids, okay? I’ve got a 26-year-old, I’ve got a 22-year-old, and I’ve got an 18-year-old. The 26, my first one guy and my daughter, they said for sure, “Yes, we want to build our houses here, okay? I’ve just bought new land over here for one of them. And if I get more money, I’ll buy one more.” This is the future for me. On the other side, it can be Palestinians, it can be Swiss, it can be Swedish, because I mean, no way. I don’t care. I want the other side not to want to kill me. This is the only thing that I want. How can it be? It’s not for me to decide.

Noam

Okay, so a question I’ve been just asking everyone here is, what is Zionism? What is this word? Are you a Zionist?

Micha

 You know, where you come from the States, you have the F word that you’re not supposed to say.

Noam 

 What is it?

Micha

 The F word.

Noam 

 What is it?

Micha

 No, no, I’m not sure if you’re allowed to say it, okay?

Noam 

 Okay.

Micha

 We have the SZ word.

Noam 

 What is that?

Micha

 Zionism.

Noam 

 You’re not allowed to say it here?

Micha

 It’s like… It’s funny, because a person can’t say on himself that he’s a Zionist.

Noam 

 Why not?

Micha

 Because it’s… It’s arrogant.

Noam 

 That’s arrogant.

Micha

I think so. I came to live here because my parents came here. I didn’t leave here because I left here. I decided to stay here and raise my family because I wanted to. Okay? I believe that staying here is the best for my family. It’s best for my community and it’s the best for my country. You want to call it Zionism? Go ahead. I call it life.

Noam 

 Fascinating. Meaning because there’s something about Zionism which is aspirational.

Micha

 Yes, because it’s like… I’m not wearing a T-shirt said, “Yes, I’m living in the envelope of Israel. I’m a Zionist.” Because I believe that there can be a person which lives in Tel Aviv, in Haifa, in Jerusalem, in Kia which is more Zionists than I am. What is the definition of a Zionist?

Noam 

 You tell me.

Micha

 I have no idea. A

Noam 

 Zionist is not someone who chooses to build the Jewish state and ensure that Jewish people have safety, sovereignty, insecurities and a democratic

Micha

 homeland. When you came to Israel and you came more than once and you decided to do a podcast in the envelope of Israel. For me, this is Zionism. Because telling our story, the story of envelope of Israel to the people abroad in the States, and I believe that your podcast is more than only in the United States, this is Zionism. You are my voice, okay? And I’m happy that you are my face because you look much better than I do.

Noam

I wanted to ask a question about something that you’re wearing. What is this that you’re wearing? What does it say?

Micha

 This is a medallion. It says over here.

Noam 

 Seven, ten, twenty, twenty-three.

Micha

 And this is the Hebrew letter of “t” “t”. It’s made for “tal”. Talqian was one of three teenagers, which were good, good, good friends of my son. They went fishing on October 7th on the beach of Zikim. Amazing kids. It was all in “nada” and “tal” from our community, from Nativ Ha’Asara. And they had another friend called “nada” from another moshav called “b’chikma”. And they were murdered on October 7th on the beach only because they went fishing. And I carry this on my heart so I’ll never forget. And I’m sitting and talking to you and Shai is bringing more groups for them. I’m doing this. This is not my occupation. I’m not a tour guide. I’m not as qualified as you are to make podcasts. I do something very different in my life. But

Noam 

 you carry this with you.

Micha

 Yes. And I have a mission. I have a mission to tell the story of the community of the Nativ Ha’Asara. We lost 20 people, 20 souls from my community.

Noam

What do you want for the future of the Nativ Ha’Asara? What do you want people to know about this place? What is the unique thing about this community that is distinct from maybe any other community?

Micha

 I’m going to tell you a story. I’ve sent you some pictures. I hope you look at the data. There are a few pictures which were taken in the cemetery, our cemetery, which is not far from our house. Two weeks after the event, I’ve joined the immediate response team a day after, on October 8th. As my brother was part of this immediate response team 15 years before me, before I did. I joined day after the October 7th. One of the missions that we took upon ourselves, 14 members of our families, which lost their loved ones, chose the loved ones to be buried in the Nativ Ha’Asara. They did want to make a temporary burial like the other places did. They wanted the loved ones to be buried over here in the cemetery of the Nativ Ha’Asara. Me and my brother, Raja, with five more members of the immediate response team, we were lucky enough to get upon ourselves the privilege of digging 14 graves and making funerals for 14 people, which I’ve known all my life. People who grew up with me, people who raised myself, people who raised me.

 When I chose to do this mission and when I chose to join the immediate response team, I got a gun. I got the best equipment that the money can buy, the military equipment. But I got the privilege, the huge privilege of protecting my community and then my family in this order. Because when I go out to fight for my community, and I know, only one thing I know for sure, if I’m going and I’m not coming back, this community will make sure that my family, all their needs will be fulfilled. They will never be alone. And this is what I want for the future of the Nativ Ha’Asara. For this community to stay the same as it is, for more generations to come, and more people come to live in the Nativ Ha’Asara and keep this idea of the Nativ Ha’Asara.

Noam

I wanted to thank you so much for your time, Micha. I love that your framing of it’s so, as an American, we just view life in a different sort of order. You talk about community to family to individual. For much of American society, it often goes in the other way, individual, family, community. But I think it’s a really helpful way to think about what it is to be Israeli. And that’s your story, community, family, individual, as opposed to individual, family, community. I’m going to think about that. So, thank you so much for your time.

Micha

 Before you leave, can I ask you for one thing? Yes. I have only one request for you. Sure. When you go back, make sure that good people like you will come to Israel, will come to the envelope of Israel, come to Nativ Ha’Asara, come see me, come see other Americans. Hear our story, tell our story. This is the only thing that I can do for the 20 people which was murdered in my community. I can’t bring them alive, but I can tell their story.

Noam 

 It is my responsibility to tell the story of the Jewish people, and your story is the story of the Jewish people.

Micha

 I highly appreciate it. Thank you very much for coming to Nativ Ha’Asara. Thank you.

[BACK TO NOAM]

Not to generalize, but many Israelis can often be stoic, speaking of horror with an almost unsettling matter-of-factness. Micha never said I am in pain. He didn’t have to. It underlined every word he spoke. But that pain clearly coexisted with an obvious and fundamental wish to do good. To build something useful and honest and dignified out of the wreckage that surrounds him. To keep the memory alive. 

To tell the story.

Which brings me back to where we started: the Tkuma Car Graveyard. These burned cars tell a story, just like the wreckage of Netiv HaAsara and the rebuilt homes at Be’eri. 

It’s a story of horror and resilience. But to the outside observer, to the person who hasn’t lived it, it’s incomplete. It tells us what the victims suffered. It doesn’t tell us who they WERE. It tells us about their deaths. Not about their lives.

So the families of the dead have stepped in to fill in the blanks. 

After October 7th, stickers began to appear in every public space in Israel. And then they spread across the world, anywhere Jews or Israelis go: Crown Heights and Prague, Montenegro and Machu Picchu. But you can’t look at them for too long, or your heart will break. Because these aren’t ordinary stickers. They’re portable memorials for every victim of 10/7 and the war that came after.

Some have QR codes to scan, so you can learn more about the 23-year-old who smiles out at you, unaware of how their life would end. Others contain quotes that embody the victims’ personalities. As I examined the stickers outside of the car graveyard, one jumped out at me. 

Noam

I was just thinking about one of the quotes over here and just reflecting on our day together. “Life is not about waiting for the storm to pass, but for life is about dancing in the rain.” Today we met with Micha in Netiv Haasara. We met with Alon in Be’eri. I was thinking about the differences between them. Their differences in age, their differences in life. Two different kibbutzim, one moshav, different communities all in the periphery right outside Gaza. All of them had the same exact idea that there are difficulty challenges around and our job is not to run away from it, not to wait for the storm to go away, but to do exactly that, which is to dance in the rain. And there is positivity, there is hope, there is optimism, even with all of the horrific things around them, even with the cemetery, the Be’eri, the beautiful paradise that became a cemetery and the difficulty moving back. But just hearing all these stories, that’s my reflection right now. Even though we’re standing right next to all these burnt cars, that’s the feeling that I’m having right now.

Shai

 I’m happy that’s your feeling. You know, a week ago I was with my daughters at the Ashkelon Beach and we were flying kites. And this little kid comes over very interested in the kites, obviously, right? And my girlfriend asks him, “What’s your name?” And he says, “Be’eri.” This is a three-year-old child, right? Obviously named after what happened. It’s just crazy, but this is Israel. I mean, this is part of being in Israel. That’s what it is. Things happen and you go on. Otherwise, right? Otherwise it wouldn’t happen. We’re saying locally that we say that if you don’t laugh, you cry.

Noam

 To laugh a lot.

Shai

 Yeah, to laugh a lot.

—

Normally, we end our episodes with five fast facts and an enduring lesson. This episode will be a little different. I’m not going to give you the fast facts. You take away what you want. What seems most relevant to you. 

But I will leave you with a final reflection.

As I stood in front of the wall of stickers, I found my thoughts straying in a morbid direction. If it had been me… if I had been in one of those cars, or in Be’eri, or Netiv Ha’Asara… what would my sticker say?

I know, it’s a dark question. But that’s what I do when I’m overwhelmed. I ponder, I intellectualize, I pick at it like it’s a thought exercise. It’s my body’s way of protecting me, I think. Turning everything into a hypothetical. Something to think about, because thinking I can handle. Feeling, though. Feeling would crush me. 

And it feels unfair, it feels self-indulgent, to fall apart when Shai and Alon and Micha tell their stories so unflinchingly. 

So I think about it. What quote my loved ones would use. How they would describe me. Of course, my mind immediately moved to Pirkei Avot, Ethics of our Fathers, one of Judaism’s most famous texts. Unlike the weighty tomes of the Gemara, which parse Jewish law, Pirkei Avot focuses entirely on the lessons that our Sages can teach us. These men lived thousands of years ago, but their names and most important sayings resonate through the centuries. 

There’s Hillel the Elder, who lends his name to countless Jewish institutions, immortalized in the statement “If I am not for myself, who will be for me? And if I am only for myself, what am I? And if not now, when?” (1:14)

There’s Hillel’s counterpart and academic rival, Shammai, who instructed his students to “Say little and do much.” (1:15)

There’s Rabbi Tarfon, who I have absolutely quoted on this podcast before, because his most famous aphorism is a perfect encapsulation of, well, being a human being with a purpose: “You are not obligated to complete the work, but neither are you free to desist from it.” (2:16)

There’s Ben Zoma, who basically unlocked the secret to happiness: “Who is rich? One who is happy with his portion.”

Generation after generation of Jewish scholars and teachers and parents kept the words of our sages alive, preserving so much wisdom that could have so easily been lost. And so, even though they departed this world millennia before I was born, these sages feel familiar to me, almost as though I know them. As though I understand their personalities and priorities. It’s an incredible reminder of the impact our words can have, if we choose them wisely. So as I lingered over sticker after heartbreaking sticker, I wondered: What is my quote? My statement? How will I be remembered? 

The men and women on these stickers didn’t get to choose their own epitaphs, their own memorials. They didn’t plan for this. Their deaths were an interruption, rather than an end to a long and satisfying life.

But reading their quotes, I got the sense that without realizing it, each had lived a life worthy of remembering, however short it was. A life worthy of immortalizing.

And maybe that’s all we can strive for.

Enjoy this podcast with friends by hosting a podcast listening party.

Subscribe to This Week Unpacked

Each week we bring you a wrap-up of all the best stories from Unpacked. Stay in the know and feel smarter about all things Jewish.